Local Researchers Overlooked in International Collaborations

Oct 23, 2019

Miriam SchuchmanMiriam Schuchman

Local researchers from sub-Saharan Africa studying the health of their own countries are often overshadowed when they work with prominent international collaborators on scientific papers, according to a new analysis by investigators at the University of Toronto, Harvard Medical School and other collaborators spanning five countries.

The findings, published on October 18 in BMJ Global Health, show the chances that a local global health researcher would be named first or senior author on a paper exploring health in sub-Saharan Africa drop drastically if the paper also includes authors from high-income countries and high-profile universities.

“Inequity in research partnerships between scholars in Africa and their collaborators in wealthy countries is a problem that blocks African researchers from moving ahead. But scholars in North America and Europe are often unaware of it, so we studied the articles that result from these partnerships to document the size of the problem,” says Miriam Shuchman, an associate professor in the Department of Psychiatry at the University of Toronto, who is a senior author of the paper.

Nicholas Neufeld, a Canadian Institutes of Health Research fellow in psychiatry at U of T, is also an author of the paper.

In an analysis of papers from 2014 to 2016 published on health in sub-Saharan Africa, a team of researchers led by Bethany Hedt-Gauthier, associate professor of global health and social medicine in the Blavatnik Institute at Harvard Medical School, found that overall representation of local authors on papers is higher than previously reported.

However, the representation of local authors, particularly in first and senior author positions, drops significantly if they collaborated with someone from a high-income country, with the most precipitous drop occurring if a collaborator is from a top-tier university.

International collaborations are crucial for global health research, the authors said, particularly given the scarcity of researchers, laboratory facilities, funding and infrastructure in most low-resource settings. These disparities make local collaborators vulnerable to intense power dynamics and put them at risk for oversight in the hierarchy of authorship.

The analysis included 7,100 articles, of which 68 per cent involved collaborators from the United States, Canada, Europe and/or another African country. More than half (54 per cent) of all 43,429 authors and 53 per cent of 7,100 first authors were from the country of the study’s focus.

Representation of local authors dropped if any of their collaborators were from the U.S., Canada, or Europe. The lowest local-author representation was on papers that featured collaborators from top U.S. universities. For these papers, 41 per cent of all authors and 23 percent of first authors were from the country of the paper’s focus. Local author representation was highest when the collaborators were from another African country. Nearly 14 per cent of all papers had no local co-authors.

This study is published alongside several other articles and commentaries that address questions of diversity and representation in global health research, echoing the findings and concerns of Hedt-Gauthier and co-authors.

This situation is fueled by the immense pressures that academic scientists face because criteria for promotions place an emphasis on peer-reviewed journal publications and citations, the study authors said.

“This dynamic incentivizes researchers from high-profile universities to push for first and senior authorship in order to advance their careers,” Hedt-Gauthier said.

To make research collaborations more equitable, to help build a corps of local researchers and to accelerate the pace of discovery in global health, universities, funders and other institutions should consider ways to change the power dynamics in research collaborations, the authors added.

In the meantime, they said, researchers in low-resource countries should consider collaborating more with one another in order to maintain visibility on the work they produce, while authors from higher-resource countries should be pushing for recognition of the local collaborators who enabled and contributed to the research.

“Collaborative and authorship dynamics are influenced by centuries of history and decades of poor practice in global health research,” Hedt-Gauthier said. “Institutions must address the systems that reinforce these dynamics, and we as individual researchers must hold ourselves accountable for promoting equity in our collaborations.”

Nov 15 Promoting Safer Opioid Prescribing for Patients With Cancer
Grand Rounds | 8:00am–9:00am
Nov 15 Food as Medicine Update 2019: Hot Topics in Nutrition Through the Lifespan
Symposium | 8:30am–4:30pm
Nov 16 Toronto International Conference on Quality in Primary Care
Conference | 8:30am–4:45pm
Nov 18 Building an Ethic of Responsibility in Indigenous Solidarity
Workshop/Seminar | 6:00pm–9:00pm
Nov 19 Here are the Fragments.
Other | 8:00am–2:00pm
Nov 20 Understanding Obesity as a Global Disease and Its Impact on Health
Lecture | 12:00pm–1:00pm
Nov 20 Publishing in the Health Sciences
Workshop/Seminar | 2:00pm–4:00pm

Tweets

UofT Medicine
@uoftmedicine
RT : Two years ago, Shintaro was airlifted to Sunnybrook with serious burns to 15% of his body. It was unclear if he'd e… https://t.co/9PnVcu8gVk
UofT Medicine
@uoftmedicine
YouTuber has Retinitis Pigmentosa & has been cared for by Prof Elise Heon for years. In a… https://t.co/QRhQgiF4Wh
UofT Medicine
@uoftmedicine
"It's a different level of empathy I have for these patients. I root for them, and when they're struggling, I reall… https://t.co/P93d8C6dcU

UofTMed Magazine

Have we lost the art of dying?

Sign up for your free digital copy.